John Purvis - Articles 2004

Emissions Trading - An Opportunity and Challenge for Scottish Business

EMISSIONS TRADING – AN OPPORTUNITY AS WELL AS A CHALLENGE FOR SCOTTISH BUSINESS

By John Purvis
Member of the European Parliament for Scotland

As part of a range of measures aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions, the European Union is to implement a new scheme in January 2005 which will set up a market across Europe for the trading of carbon dioxide emissions. Under the Emissions Trading Scheme, national governments will allocate an emission allowance to individual companies. Any that is able to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions to below its quota will be able to sell the unused portion to other companies within the EU that have exceeded their own allowance.

The scheme offers industry a double incentive to introduce technological innovation. As well as the reduced costs from more efficient operation, the sale of emission permits will enhance company bottom lines. The Scheme also offers the opportunity for businesses to develop trading links with counterparts in other countries. With the 10 new Accession States likely to see the greatest growth across Europe in years to come, the development of links with these emerging countries would be an astute move by any company wishing to develop and expand.

Background

The EU has agreed to an overall reduction of 8% of its 1990 level of emissions by 2010, with the UK's share being 12.5%. The Emissions Trading Scheme is part of a whole programme of EU environmental legislation aimed at reducing emissions, including promotion of renewal energy, biofuels, combined heat and power, improved energy efficiency, and improvements in the transport and waste management sectors. It will also work alongside requirements for efficient use of energy in installations in the Directive on Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control.

Implementation of the Emissions Trading Scheme

The EU scheme will start in January 2005 and is mandatory for electricity generators exceeding a thermal input threshold of 20 MW, oil refineries, iron and steel manufacturers, paper, pulp and board manufacturers and the mineral industry - which account for about 50% of all of the UK's CO² emissions. Each EU country must devise its own National Allocation Plan, setting out total allowances allocated to the different industry sectors and how they will be distributed between individual installations. By the end of March 2004, all installations covered by the scheme must hold a trading permit. Installation allowances will be allocated by the end of February each year and must be surrendered by the end of April the following year.

The European Parliament is also hoping to be able to extend the Scheme to allow companies to acquire credits by financing projects in and transferring know-how to developing countries or countries whose economies are in transition. This would help poorer countries use energy more efficiently and develop in a more sustainable way.

UK plans for emission reduction

The UK's plan, agreed between the UK Government and the devolved administrations, aims to reduce CO² emissions by 20% - stricter than the EU requirement. Scotland, which produces about 12% of the UK's total carbon emissions, wants to make its due contribution to meeting this target, but it faces a greater challenge. Between 1990 and 1998 the UK's emissions as a whole dropped by 9%, whilst Scotland’s emissions only reduced by 3%. Over the same period, emissions from the Scottish energy sector increased by over 13%, largely due to an increase in coal-fired electricity exports to England.

Scotland has the ambitious target of generating 17-18% of its electricity from renewable sources by 2010 – though it is doubtful if these targets can be reached with renewable energy sources still at an early stage of development. Wave power is emerging as a very promising energy source, but is not yet commercially operable. Energy from wind power is technologically proven but an enormous number of wind turbines will have to be built to meet demand and they are still not able to produce a predictable or constant supply. They are also beginning to excite public resistance. Nuclear energy is able to produce large volumes of electricity with very few greenhouse gas emissions, but the UK Government has decided not to replace older plants, making Scotland’s emissions' targets even harder to reach.

Nevertheless, emissions trading may be a good opportunity for Scottish companies to increase their profits and help improve our environment. Meeting our emissions targets is a major challenge. Emissions trading should help to square this difficult circle.

John Purvis MEP
Vice Chairman of the European Parliament's Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee
and Member of the European Parliament’s Committee on Industry, External Trade, Research and Energy.